| Review
of
Riddled with Life, by Marlene Zuk (Hardcover, 2007)
Reviewer:
Mark Lamendola, author of over 6,000 articles.
My life began with a years-long struggle against
life-draining parasites (I refer to viruses and bacteria, not members of
Congress). Unlike most kids, I spent most of my first decade making my
parents wonder if I'd see another birthday. As you might suspect, this
book is
very interesting to me on a personal level.
And that brings us to the question of whether this book
would be interesting to you. If you have spent much of your life
fighting off one disease after another, then obviously yes. But what if
you're the typical person who had the usual childhood illnesses and
occasionally gets a cold? You take all of the precautions, and you even
use antibacterial soaps. If that's the case, then this book is even more
applicable to you than it is to me.
Zuk tackles one myth after another, to help the reader
gain valuable perspective. I haven't seen any negative reviews of this
book so far, but invariably someone will cherry-pick excerpts and argue
that Zuk is contradicting herself. Zuk says our bodies and environments are
so full of bacteria and other parasites that obsessing over getting rid of
them is rather pointless and probably harms us. But she also talks about the benefits of sanitation and
hygienic practices.
So, is she trying to have it both ways? This is like
asking if it makes sense to get both rest and exercise, which are two
seemingly contradictory activities. In fact, they are complementary
activities. You need a balance of each.
Balance is exactly what Zuk brings to the discussion of
parasites. She gives the example of installing an antibacterial welcome mat
for the "safety" of your baby. This might make a parent feel good, but
serves no other purpose. But such an act isn't necessarily harmless--it
can tilt the balance of the bacterial population such that the baby
encounters only superbugs. This type of problem exists on many fronts,
and Zuk makes a fascinating exploration of them.
Not all bacteria are bad, and Zuk is quite clear about
this. The harsh chemicals that saved my life on several occasions (while
also running up large medical bills) destroyed more than the harmful
bugs. One of the side effects was the inability to digest foods like
nuts--the little nut parts would go straight through, exiting in
exactly the condition I swallowed them (sharp edges and all).
You can simulate the feeling of passing undigested nuts
(with their tiny sharp edges) by
using 60 grit sandpaper on your rear end. I don't recommend that you
stop and do it right now, but if you're so inclined then that's fine.
Most of us can simply appreciate the concept and understand the point
being made. It's also true some folks get an approximation of this from
the cheap paper provided by their employer....
It took many years to correct just this one side effect
from killing bugs. In my case, the initial problem was a necessary side
effect of a life-saving measure. But today, people are indiscriminately
applying harsh chemicals and creating all kinds of unpleasant and
presumably unintended consequences. And not just for themselves. Nuking every little
critter isn't a wise strategy. In fact, many of those little critters
may be your ticket to health.
I was born with an immune deficiency and still have it.
Yes, I keep my home very clean. But Zuk would be proud of me because I
work in the soil, gardening with bare hands. As a little kid, I also spent a lot of time
playing in the dirt. I needed something in that prairie soil, and
apparently I got it. I haven't been sick now since 1971--even with my
immune deficiency. Bacteria. You can't live with 'em and you
can't live without 'em. (Note my wellness isn't just from playing in the
dirt. See
www.supplecity.com for info).
Now that I've addressed the major sticking point of this book
(the only good bug is a dead bug--not true!), I want to
comment on Zuk's writing style. She laces her prose with a subtle humor
that immediately reminded me of some friends in New Zealand. Now I
can get in big trouble for saying this, but Aussies and Kiwis are
similar in many ways. I wasn't surprised when she revealed that she had
spent considerable time in Australia.
So, what's really in this book? Lots of amazing facts, for sure. It has 11
chapters, extensive references, and a thorough index. Good insights,
thought-provoking questions, interesting anecdotes, and a crisp writing
style sprinkled with humor all work together to make it both useful and
enjoyable.
This book addresses several complex topics, and
presents them in a manner that allows the layman to follow along and
understand. It's hard to pick out just one topic and address it
properly, so I'll just name a few topics. If you read the book, you'll
enjoy Zuk's explanations. Topics include:
- Testosterone poisoning.
- Why roosters have red combs.
- The upside of eating worms.
- Why not completing a medication protocol even
though you now feel fine is a bad idea.
- Why you can't possibly make yourself sick by
violating some of today's commonly accepted rules of hygiene.
- Health products that are a complete rip-off
(and why).
- The evolutionary interaction between
parasites and their hosts.
And, everyone's favorite topic. I speak, of
course, of sex. Each of four chapters is devoted to a different aspect
of the this topic, and other chapters also cover it in some way or
another. Yes, even sex has been influenced heavily by bugs. In fact,
bugs may be the very reason for it. Who woulda thunk? Maybe we should
establish Thank A Bacterium Day.
Bacteria and viruses are intertwined with us, and Zuk makes a good case
for the concept that our bodies are what they are because of the
critters rather than in spite of
them. But, it doesn't stop there. Zuk also presents strong evidence that
our very minds are influenced by parasites (thus explaining the US Tax
Code). The final chapter of the book and Zuk's closing remark may well
reshape your view of the world and other people in it. |