Review of
Enough: Staying Human in an Engineered Age, by Bill McKibben
Reviewer: Mark Lamendola, IEEE Senior Member, 2003 IEEE Region 5 Outstanding
Member, and author of over 3500 articles. The
May 14, 2003 issue of the Wall Street Journal had an article by John
J. Miller, in which Miller quoted none other than Ray Bradbury on the
topic of cloning. One might think Bradbury would be all for it. Instead,
he says, "It's better to go to be and make a baby, isn't it?"
The issues behind such a statement go far beyond
the pleasure aspect, as McKibben—who is no enemy of science or scientists
- so aptly and persuasively points out. In Enough, McKibben takes
us on a thought-provoking journey of logic, where we examine the issues
behind such things as germline engineering, nanotechnology, and robotics.
He persuasively explaines the folly of technology for technology's sake,
and helps us draw the line between that which is beneficial and that
which is not. In other words, that which is enough and that which is
over the line.
I very much like the way McKibben explodes the
myth that folks who develop technology are experts in how it should
be used. Many people who provide us with assurances on the value of
a given technology is - no matter how far it's taken - aren't qualified.
A case in point is television. Heralded in its early days as something
that would bring to every citizen a vast knowledge and appreciation
of history, the arts, and higher learning - it is, instead, an electronic
lobotomizer.
McKibben does more than provide several compelling
arguments as to why assurances by technologists are unreliable - despite
the best of intentions. He goes on to explain the consequences to technology
developers, end-users, and society at large, when we don't look at technology
from a wider perspective than the assumption our role is to continually
develop and employ it.
If you like to scratch the surface of important
questions, this book is more than enough - without being too much. If
you are at the other end of the spectrum and like to deeply ponder complex
questions of what makes us human and what our technological limits are
in light of that, this book is enough to fuel the flames. The one flaw
in Enough is it simply is not enough. While it was satisfying
on many levels, it left me wanting to read McKibben's other books. I'll
read his "Then End of Nature," but I will impatiently wait
for his next book. If all of McKibben's books are of this caliber, I'm
not sure we'll ever have enough of them. |